**Please note that my kids are 10, 8, and 3, so this list is either items I have bought or would buy for these particular ages. Many of these items are appropriate for varying ages.
Baseball, football, or other theme. My son loves the thrill of opening a new pack! As a larger, separate gift, you can give a 3-ring binder with clear sectioned sleeves to store the cards (available wherever cards are sold)
A fun, vintage toy for any boy, any age! (Cracker Barrel)
My girls love new ponytail holders, headbands, barrettes, bobby pins.
(Walmart or Target)
These inexpensive silicone watches come in bright, fun colors and styles
Claire’s Boutique carries multiple sets in fun, girly styles
Crackle polish is all the rage for little and big girls alike! Any drugstore carries crackle as well as hundreds of other fun choices!
Gel pens, mechanical pencils, markers, fresh crayons, Sharpie pens in wild colors
Itunes, Sonic, Chik-fil-a, Yogurt store, Movie Theater, or other favorite place they can get a small “treat”
My kids all have their favorite sweet treat. $1 boxes at discount stores, plastic tube candy canes filled with favorite candy, LifeSaver books (remember those?), mints or gum, sack of chocolate coins, and I even found this blast from the past gum at Cracker Barrel. Loved this as a kid!
(Cracker Barrel store)
Shaped like an ornament (Wal-Mart)